A Rejected Paper Beats an Unwritten One

A Rejected Paper Beats an Unwritten One

1. The Idea

Losing does not make you a loser. Not even trying is the real loss. Just do your best and shoot. Even if you lose, you get feedback, and that is so much better than doing nothing.

2. Related Quote

“You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take.”

Wayne Gretzky

3. Why This Matters to You

Most of academic life is losing. Most papers get rejected, most grant proposals go unfunded, and most job applications go nowhere. A submission that fails still comes back with reviews from experts who read your work closely, and that kind of feedback is hard to get any other way. The draft that stays in a folder waiting to be perfect teaches you nothing and counts for nothing when your tenure file or funding record gets reviewed. If you shoot more often, you lose more often, and you also learn faster and give yourself more chances to land the one that counts.

4. Counter Viewpoint

Every shot costs something. A weak grant proposal eats weeks you could have spent on a stronger one. A rushed paper burns reviewer time and can mark your name in a small field. Many rejections also come back with a single line or no reasons at all, so the feedback you hoped for never arrives. So the real question is which attempts deserve your limited time and energy, and the answer to that may not always be to shoot.

About simo 

Simo is an award-winning professor, research group leader, and builder who wants you to kick butt in academia. He writes about the simple systems that make research easier and the days a lot more fun.

Academic life can be good. Let's make yours.

A six-day series on taking back control of your days, plus notes from someone knee-deep in the game. 100% free, one click to leave, read by hundreds already, and known to make you spill your coffee.